Graf Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Graf bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

Moving to Grafenwoehr

who's talking here?

Elizabeth 3
Lefteous 19
Jeeze Louise 9
a1639983uu 3
earthycrunchy 1
a3081011uu 4
Mommygirl81 13

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a3081011uu --- 15 years ago -

Thinking of starting a book club that studies the Bible. NOT a "Bible study" the way most know it; this would be something that anyone could do. Athiest, agnostic, Christian, Jewish, Muslim...whoever. The Bible is one of the oldest texts and people take so many views on it's contents that I am curious to hear what a study of it by any interested person would bring. What do you think? 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

sounds like a wolf in sheep's clothing...

Why not study the Koran instead?

or the Aenid of Virgil? 

earthycrunchy --- 15 years ago -

Their is a book called the Bible as History, the author is Werner Keller. It's very interesting. Their is also a book called A History of God, the author is Karen Armstrong. 

a3081011uu --- 15 years ago -

a3177662uu: How does what I said [i]sounds like a wolf in sheep's clothing...
? Why not the Koran or Virgil? Well, because they do not have quite the history of the Jewish/Christian Bible, and because those are not the books I wish to discuss right now. Though I would have no problem reading and discussing either.[/i]

Justin: It is better to do your own research. I would rather study something myself than have someone else give me their opinion/research on it. Especially if it is something I know little about or know only second hand; I would not see possible discrepancies were I to read someone else's work without first having studied the topic. Plus, there is a better chance that you'll come away more educated than less when you do it yourself. Too many people trust their minds to someone else these days and lack the faith to believe they can formulate their own opinion based on the facts. Or....people are just too lazy to do the work required to find the truth. (it being so much easier to let someone else tell you what to think) 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

This bible study sounds like a recruitment tool to me, wittingly or not. Inviting people of all beliefs for an open discussion about an ancient text sounds harmless, so people come with an investigative mindset. During the course of such study they take the contents seriously. The theory of Cognitive dissonance then predicts that people will believe in the veracity of what they are taking so seriously, because it would be ridiculous to devote so much time and energy to it otherwise. That is the short of it.

You can see recruitment utilizing cognitive dissonance theory on a regular basis. I first became aware of it in the baptist church, but they certainly aren't alone in using it. Visit any baptist service, and sometime during the service they will address people who are unsure about their religious convictions. They will invite those people to talk with them after the service, to investigate their questions. They will pray to the lord for guidance. It is a point of social politeness that if someone calls a small group to prayer, then all will be polite enough to join in as a sign of respect to the beliefs of others. But cognitive dissonance will not allow a person to wonder if there is a god while he is on his knees praying to that god. If there is no god wouldn't it be pretty silly to be there on your knees asking him for guidance? Well, you can't change the fact that you are on your knees, so, without a shred of knowledge, your mind tricks you into becoming a believer.

None of this is to say that you are attempting to manipulate anyone. While you may be a christian (because I assume you are talking about studying a christian bible), you may be someone who is simply entertaining your own questions of belief.

I think differently than you do in regard to reading other people's work. If I had to do the basic research required to acquire knowledge, I would be stuck in some hunter gatherer phase. To borrow a phrase, I stand on the shoulders of giants. Imagine discovering for yourself that the planets orbit the sun - discovering for yourself the mathematics and physics of it. One of the dangers in assimilating what others have discovered, of course, is that we do learn things that aren't true.

One of those things people learn that isn't true is about religion, and it coincides with your comment about too many people trusting their minds to someone else. I have yet to meet a person who believes in the god of the bible based upon their own intelligence or observation. Everyone I know has come to that belief because of someone else telling them about it. To me, it is a shame, because people have turned to mysticism and magic, thereby turning away from reason. But I do accept electrical theory without ever having seen an electron - and when I flip the switch and the light doesn't go on, I don't think it is because the gods are angry. 

Elizabeth --- 15 years ago -

Do you really have to troll SO much? Don't you have ANYTHING else to do?? 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

@Elizabeth - I assume you are talking to me. I don't understand your consternation though.

I try never to be impolite or make personal accusations that are negative. I will allow that some people have taken them as such, but I will also say that the people who have felt personally criticized read that criticism into the response and is not what I actually wrote.

The original poster (OP) asked about bible study - I made a short response - he responded back - I made a longer response. Kinda what this forum is for isn't it?

Frankly, it seems to me that the OP is open to alternative thoughts and ideas. In fact, he asked for them in the framework of his bible study. Elizabeth, you'll certainly agree that mine are generally VERY alternative. I think that the OP will be able to accept my thoughts and opinions as my thoughts and opinions, rather than as some kind of attack of any position he may hold.

Oh, and yes, you don't know how bored I really am, want to have coffee? 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

a31776622uu Why don't you try a hobby? Quilting, reading, volunteering, something... 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

What is the objection to taking part in a discussion forum? 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

You're the one who claimed to be bored. Just sayin'... 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

I see. Thank you for the suggestions. 

Elizabeth --- 15 years ago -

I could never have coffee or even be in the presence of the likes of you without having to stifle my vomit. You make me and probably everyone else here sick with what you've had to say. You've completely ruined your credibility on this site. It's no wonder you hide behind a generic name. 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

LMAO @Elizabeth, I like how you say what's on everyone's mind. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

@Elizabeth - your two posts on this thread have been nothing but personal comments about me.

My bet is that the OP has never heard of cognitive dissonance, and rather than making a precipitous response he is busy looking into it. When he figures out what he needs to know, one way or the other, he will probably respond. That is what inquisitive people do.

I'm not sure of what I have written that makes you sick. Is it simply that I have thoughts and ideas that are not in the mainstream, and that you cannot abide anyone who thinks differently than you do? If we all have to think alike, then what is the use of having your own thoughts? I certainly can accept that you have your thoughts and ideas. Why do mine threaten you so much?

Credibility? Do you think I have lied somewhere here?

Forums like these seem to have a lot of uses, including discussion and exchanges of ideas. I don't know what a name, generic or not, will contribute to an idea. More to the point, why is it important to you that other people know your name?

Do you, Elizabeth, have anything to discuss, or are you only interested in hurling blind insults? 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

@a317...you've already stated you're bored. It seems you make these posts to stir up some drama/controversy. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

I see.

I don't decide if there is controversy or drama surrounding my posts. That is a decision made by the people who read them. I do know, as I said before, that many of my opinions are not mainstream. I try very hard to represent them as my opinions, and not to suggest that everyone should think as I do.

I try to read other opinions and react to them without making personal attacks. For instance, in my longer response in this thread above, "none of this is to say that you are attempting to manipulate anyone" removes any suggestion of a personal criticism.

The drama and controversy comes with name calling, like troll, and visceral reponses like "you make me sick." These are emotional responses and have nothing to do with reason. Well, I have emotions too, but they really don't do anything constructive in a discussion and exchange of thoughts and ideas. In fact, when the emotions come out, reason generally shuts down.

If Elizabeth thinks that my thoughts and ideas are wrong, perhaps she could present a counterargument, or even mention what I have written that she finds offensive. I am always interested in understanding the arguments surrounding whatever we are discussing. This does not mean that I will accept them as my own. 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

The problem is that you don't stop. No one can present a counterargument because you just want to go around and around with them. If you have an opinion, state it and leave it at that. And really, you've stated many opinions that are "not mainstream" as you put it, but ridiculous to everyone else. You've said you're bored, asked someone to coffee even. Does it surprise you that you repel people? And yes, you do decide if what you're saying is controversial. I'm sure I have a whole lot of controversial opinions but I don't post them just to get under other people's skin so that I have something to alleviate the boredom. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Rereading this thread, I can see that the OP started, got a response from Justin and myself, then the OP made a longer post in which he asked me for clarification of what I meant in my first post, stated a positiion he held, and expressed a belief and provided information to explain why he believed so.

To that I replied with the clarification the OP asked for, a personal experience, an opinion I had that differed from his with the reasons I differ, and then I noted a conundrum within myself.

Following that are just comments about me as a person from you and Elizabeth. You have been civil and respectable, Elizabeth's has not been so. Nevertheless, the focus of the posts has not been to present a counterargument or about anything that can be remotely tied to the OP's post - just personal comments from you and personal attacks from Elizabeth.

I did remark about being bored, but I think you understood it to be a stronger remark than I meant it to be. I really had no illusions that Elizabeth would meet for coffee. It was nice of you to offer suggestions for things to do, and I'm sorry that I initially understood them as a personal criticism.

Perhaps if you or Elizabeth could take one of my comments in this thread that you think is ridiculous, then state your opinion of the subject and tell us why you think so, then we could get back to sharing thoughts and ideas :) 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

I apologize to the OP that this thread got off subject. Should we start one specifically about you? Joking, joking... I was making comments about ALL of your posts, not just on this thread. You're very forceful with your opinions. I think most people take that badly. 

Jeeze Louise --- 15 years ago -

a3177... you may think you are offering "alternative viewpoints" but I just think you're weird. When I am out and about and I see funky looking "alternative" people, I wonder am I looking at you LMBO.

I've got quite an imagination and I'm a bored housewife...

... so I envision you to be one of those dirty hippy types with greasy unkempt hair and hairy armpits who are all wiccan and into tantric sex. I imagine that you give your children odd names to be "modern" and your son is named "Gin" after your favorite liquor and your daughter is named "Kool" after your fave smokes. You don't care that your boy wants to be a "princess" so you let him wear a tinkerbell costume for Fasching while daughter dear is dressed like a pirate. I imagine you wear big gawdy costume jewelry and favor midwest native american styles with tons of turquoise.

Just my opinion LMBO (O_o) 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

@Bookoo Fanatic, LMFAO!!! 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

BF don't you remember? You asked me once if you could borrow my sandals that I made out of a tire! I told you no because they were still under warranty! But before you left we sang Kumbayah!

MG81, I think a lot of times I express considered opinions that challenge the opinions that others have but have not thought about. It is easy to say, "I believe this way," but very often people can't explain why. So when I say that I think a different way and have the reasons for it, they can't reply with their reasons, and end up getting really defensive, and their responses turn out to be emotional rather than rational.

When that happens, I might challenge people to think about the "why" because their emotional responses really don't interest me. When I do that, it seems that people react as if I am overly pushy. It is challenging to think about the "whys." It is easier to feel rather than think, but much less reliable. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Of course it is OK to have opinions that differ - happens all the time.

Look at the abortion debate in the US for instance. There are more than two sides to that issue and all of them are valid based upon the morality of the person having the opinion. But for someone to say that they have a position on it and then don't know why - well I end up thinking that they don't have an opinion at all, they are just using someone else's without thinking about it. 

Jeeze Louise --- 15 years ago -

Glad you think it's a joke a3177... but just so we are clear, I will state it plain and simple...

I -- DON'T -- LIKE -- YOU

Yes, I am being judgemental and I frankly don't care. YOU ARE WEIRD. I don't like weird people in my life. I like being boring, moral, and square. I am offended by people who excuse their immorality behind wacky logic and faulty reasoning. I also don't like people who sprinkle their speech/writing with the occasional big word in the attempt to seem smarter than what they really are.

And I would never ask to borrow anything from you because I honestly believe you probably only shower once a week and I think that's nasty, bless your heart.

Cleanliness is next to Godliness, my Grammy always said. 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

Bless your heart...we all know what that means! LMBO!!! 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

@BF Thank you dear, I'm not sure who wasn't clear on that point already.

Since we have never met, your criticisms are not really judgmental. You have never met me to make the judgments you are talking about. I'm not in your life.

I will take you at your word though. As you said in a previous post, you use your imagination. Like a child with an imaginary friend, you have me as an imaginary enemy. The truth is more like this: you may not be my friend, but I am not your enemy.

The proper assault on wacky logic and faulty reasoning is a reasoned rebuttal. Why is it that all you have to offer is insulting accusations that you have dreamed up? Have you resorted to an emotional response because reason has failed you?

I could act like I am in kindergarten. I could call you names. I could say that you suck like a whore whose rent is due. I could accuse you of being a nasty wife whose only exercise is running the Fat Lady 500 in the candy aisle of the commissary. If I practised, I could become as insulting as you are, but what would it do for me? The answer is nothing. It wouldn't help me to make a single convincing argument about anything.

You - don't - like - me because I - challenge - you - and - you - can't - think - about - the - issue.

I think that all you can think about is that someone challenged you and you have to destroy them. You choose to do that by making personal attack instead of reasoned counterarguments. That leads me to think that you cannot develop a reasoned counterargument.

Did you know that half of all Americans have an IQ that is below average? That is a fact - a fact that President Eisenhower once refused to believe. I occasionally need a reminder of it. Do you know what an adverb is?

@MG81 - I believe you have reason in you - you showed it to me a few posts ago - work on developing it - don't follow the crowd into behaving stupidly or you will end up in the sea with the lemmings. 

Jeeze Louise --- 15 years ago -

You're an idiot and we all know it.

My IQ is very healthy, thank you very much, haven't been tested lately, but I do know it is defintely higher than Forrest Gump levels LOL. Maybe a little shy of Mensa, but who wants to chillax with a bunch of egghead nerds anyway???

You are not my enemy, never said you were. I don't fantasize about you, but I do infer things about you from what and how you post. And I didn't call you names, though considering how you feel on cheating, "whore" would be fitting. I simply said I envision you to be a stinky unwashed hippy. And I am a big woman, though 500lbs is a bit of an exaggeration. I'm still gorgeous, jelly rolls and all. "Chunky but Funky" is my motto. And that's Funky as in "play that funky music white boy" not "dirty stinky hippy" funky.

You don't challenge me actually. I don't debate with fools (O_o). No need to try and explain our own point of view to someone who is attempting to shove theirs down our throats... you showed that on the cheater thread, did you not? When people tried to "debate" you, you just waved your, "I'm intellectually superior" wand for being able to think immorally and defend it with your own witty logic.

And heck, what's the fun in being a smarty pants if I can't be a sarcastic little troll and bother you???

And as far as lemmings, I guess MG81 can be mine... especially considering we are FrIeNdS, something I doubt you have many of.

And MG81, thanks for the enchilada thingies, my dearest lemming. Would you like to follow me off a cliff or possibly to OBI Tuesday??? 

Jeeze Louise --- 15 years ago -

Ahhh... I had to re-read some of your very old posts... you used to make some sense. I guess I stopped respecting you after the cheating thread, mainly because I thought you were a whorish military wife trying to excuse your whore ways. But after re-reading some things, I think you're a dude, retired or either civilian. Kinda puts a different perspective on some of your more recent posts. You also like to play devil's advocate which I can respect.

...But you're still a whore, atleast mentally (>_ 

Mommygirl81 --- 15 years ago -

@a3177...I'm reasonable but I also find it HILARIOUS when someone pulls out the "bless your heart" line. I'm with BF and find you a little too forceful with your opinions. Sure, debate away, but if you want a debate you can't blow the other person off because they're not bowing to your argument. Yeah, I'll give you that a lot of people have no idea why they feel the way they do or only believe in something because they were raised that way. But the few of us that actually understand our opinions don't need your bullying. BTW, I don't need to work on developing my reasoning abilities. You need to work on your sense of humor!

@BF, girl, you crack me up! I'd follow you anywhere, be it off a cliff or to OBI! 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Please read the "all the women" thread again. Notice that the first few posts were just intended to throw in a few witty interjections. My more provocative posts are longer (as you well know). My later posts changed a bit to emphasize family togetherness and moved farther away from the cheating question. You will see that I never said I was a woman, but I did let people think I was.

It is a hard task to empathize with another - to understand the feelings, thoughts, and experiences of another without actually having the feelings, thoughts and experiences. Try to think of my character in that thread as a character in a play.

This character was once married and had children. He had also been a soldier.

This soldier left his family often and for long periods of time while he was playing army. Eventually his wife got tired of sacrificing her family, and left him to find a life that was more suited to her. Oddly, whether or not she "cheated" is actually irrelevant. If she did, it may have hurt at the time but would be shortly forgotten.

Years passed. The soldier continued his career. The ex-wife married another man who ended up raising his children. Through time and distance he grew apart from his children until they were adults that he hardly knew.

The soldier finally realized the mistake he made. He had failed in his greatest duty - the duty to his family. He had left them too often and too long. He realized that they had deserved more OF him, not more FROM him.

He thought he was doing what men do - supporting them. He was giving them a good life; security, happiness, comfort. But all they remember is that he was never there. And when he was there, it was just to get ready to leave again. He had let his wife go to another man, his children to know that man better than they knew him.

The old soldier had retired, but still had contact to Army people. He tried to tell them the mistakes that they were making, outcomes that they couldn't foresee, but they didn't have the experience to understand. The army's propaganda - oops, command information - machine was too efficient. They told the soldier the same dogma that he had spouted in his youth; service to country, good job, blah blah. And he watched helplessly as history repeated itself.

Now, as you reread the thread and think of the character I portray in that light, does it make any more sense?

Well, some wives stay, some wives go, but all wives keep the kids. The wives who were posting accepted the separations as part of the natural order of having employment, income, safety, honor, and one said, "a future for her kids." They are trading the possibility of his death or injury in exchange for these things, or they feel powerless to prevent it. Accepting the separations is OK - its a personal choice. But they are also making that choice for their kids. And what happens when the soldier comes back changed, or not at all?

@BF Yes, I sometimes do play the devil's advocate - that is what I mean when I talk about challenging people's opinions and ideas. Also my allusion to the Fat Lady 500, was a takeoff on the Indianapolis 500, it wasn't to suggest that you weigh 500lbs.

@MG81 Did I miss something? I don't recall a "bless your heart" line. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
help
graf
religion

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Graf Underground