Graf Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Graf bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

The Animal Shelter Discussion

who's talking here?

Elizabeth 2
Kate 1
EuropeanTravel 2
Jeeze Louise 1
Frogdog 4
earthycrunchy 3
Shubunkin 4
Kikawow 3
a3253716uu 1
pauljw82 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Frogdog --- 15 years ago -

Ok since there are a few postings on Grafenwoehryardsales about the Amberg Animal shelter and you can't really respond to it (beside you write every person), I thought we start a discussion about this matter.
So share your thoughts!

If you don't know what the matter is: an American family went to the Amberg shelter and didn't get a dog cause they're Americans. 

Jeeze Louise --- 15 years ago -

Considering many of the local shelters are filled with dogs and other animals abandoned by Americans, I can understand why they refuse to adopt out to us. Just my opinion. 

Frogdog --- 15 years ago -

THis is my email I wrote back to that lady:
"Sorry that you didn't get a dog from the animal shelter, BUT there are many reasons for that why they do not adopt out to Americans, they are certainly not racist!!! They have long time experience with dogs coming back to the shelter when a soldier is PCS'ing, deploying or the dog is just not as perfect as the person expected it to be. Almost all dogs sitting in the Weiden and Amberg shelters are from Americans! They got abandoned because of the above mentioned reasons. The shelter employees are looking for a forever home for those dogs and not just till something comes up within the next few years in the new owners life.Of course they can not seperate the good from the bad, cause they have been dissappointed so many times.Maybe try a breeder to get the wanted pooch or look on the advertisements, there's always dogs which are getting rehomed." 

Kate --- 15 years ago -

The shelters are racist! Denying someone simply because they are American is discrimination.

However, I do understand why they do it. Take a look at Grafyardsales, over and over I see dogs being passed around here, take one of these dogs and give them a forever home! As far as most dogs in the shelter just being from Americans I find that hard to believe, Im sure a lot come from the Germans to.

I think many people need to take a different approach to adding a pet to there home. Do your research on breeds find what works for you, take in consideration the commentiment you are taking on, not only financial but time consuming. If you haven't thought of these maybe do a little dog sitting before hand, you would be helping a family out and also getting a little taste of the responsibility.

This is just my two cents. Doesn't mean it's right or wrong. 

Shubunkin --- 15 years ago -

here was my post:

It makes me pretty upset that some lady came on here and was like "I run an animal shelter- you should adopt dogs" blah blah blah. Here in Germany we are all being punished for some American's mistakes. Why should we support the animal shelters when they won't even let us adopt dogs from their shelters? I understand some American families totally suck by not taking their pets- and leaving them here- but punishing ALL Americans and not letting them try to right someone else's wrong and do something good by adopting a dog is completely ridiculous! I guess that's ok- German breeders are making a hefty hunk of change from the American's who want pets.


The shelter should at least try to be fair... perhaps by making Americans sign a legal binding document saying they will take the dog with them when they PCS- or they will have to pay more than what it costs to ship the pet in a fine. Make the Americans provide the travel documentation as proof. Don't just say "You are American you no take dog." Some shelters require you to show documentation on getting the pet spayed or neutered. If people are really serious about adopting a dog and keeping it forever then providing documents and signing papers shouldn't be an issue. We should at least be given a chance to adopt a dog from a shelter!!! 

Elizabeth --- 15 years ago -

I don't care if they won't adopt out to people who part their hair to the right for that matter, as long as they are doing the best they can to make sure those pets get to a likely forever home that's fine with me. I agree with them not adopting out to people that are going to end up leaving the country within a few years and will have trouble bringing the pet along, or the infamous women who for some reason can no longer open a back door to let a dog go out to pee simply because a new baby is in the house, or the even better idiots who realize after the fact that having a big German Shepherd or Husky isn't the best idea when living in stairwell housing.
They have every right to try to give those animals a good home, even if it means being hard on or not allowing us Americans. If you don't like it, come back here tomorrow, there will be someone else on here getting rid of their pet for some stupid excuse, or pick up the Stars and Stripes paper, there are plenty of pets in there. 

Shubunkin --- 15 years ago -

Almost all dog's problems are the owner's fault. Dog psychology: got to sometimes think like a dog- to obtain the type of dog you want. It takes time and consistency but lots of problems with dogs are correctable. Ppl should have to take a test to be able to own a dog. They do temperment tests for dogs here- why not administer intelligence tests for wanna be pet owners. 

Shubunkin --- 15 years ago -

Some people want to have that great feeling of knowing they saved a dog that was on death row. 

earthycrunchy --- 15 years ago -

I think IT'S AWESOME that they will not let American's adopt from their shelters. I get that not all American's do this to their animals but when you run a shelter that is 99% filled with dogs from American families it's nice to see them standing up for the dog!
American's should be ashamed of the way they act. Lately the talk around my town is how awful things will be when the troops return and businesses are already talking about when they start banning American's because of their bad behavior. 

Shubunkin --- 15 years ago -

Why are we even here to begin with? Hitler was removed from power ages ago!
We are just boosting the German economy by living here. 

earthycrunchy --- 15 years ago -

I actually think having bases in other countries is good, it helps American's understand that the world is not all about them.....too bad it doesn't seem to be helping. 

a3253716uu --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it's just because we are Americans, it's because we are military as well. Most of us are only here for a set amount of time and PCSing with pets is a pain. My husband and I ran into this problem even in the states. We were denied at two different shelters because we are military. Unfortunately the many who adopt pets just to get rid of them once they are inconvenient ruin it for the good pet owners. The one thing I have seen about Germans is they really love their pets and just want to make sure they are properly taken care of. I can respect that. 

earthycrunchy --- 15 years ago -

A3, good point about the shelters in the states as I well, I too have heard this before. 

EuropeanTravel --- 15 years ago -

Funny I know someone who helps out at the shelters here. They are german/american. They don't deny you because you ARE american or ARE military. No one you have to speak german because the workers speak german. Two you have to visit MULTIPLE times the same dog for like 30min-1hr. It's a long process but they want to see commitment. It's not like in the states where you walk in want it and get it. That's how the shelter my friend worked at ran anyway. So some people were probably rude, or sketchy to them so they didn't want to deal with it. They give a crap about the animals here alot more than in the states. It's frustrating when people open their mouths and don't know the full story or truths. Yes some shelters may discriminate but can you blame them? If they wanted a pet so bad why not wait the what 2-3yrs until they are back in the states and get one. Then they don't have to pay for the vet bills or plane ticket. It's also a note that some soldiers choose the 2yr here and their family stays behind where they can adopt and have access to animals like they are a narcotic. Get one, get rid of it, get one, get rid of it etc.. Not saying everyone is like that but if they truly wanted a pet they would go through a breeder or wait. There are shelters in other parts of europe that will adopt out just to get their capacity down however you have to be weary of diseases, heartworms etc.. It's not impossible to get a pet here and it is not hard to wait until you are back in the states. Getting a pet should NEVER be on impulse anyway. I'm not implying that the person who went and could'nt get one was being impulsive just saying the majority of people are impulse buyers/adopters. 

EuropeanTravel --- 15 years ago -

I also have not run into a problem being military affiliated in getting a pet. Be upfront and say yes you travel however you have this much time until you move here. The pet will be going etc.. Don't get a pet a few months before moving and don't get a pet first thing when you get somewhere. Common sense. Traveling is stressful for a pet learning to live in a new home and when you move somewhere the honeymoon period will wear off and you may end up with a bundle you were not ready for. Also clear a pet with the post or your landlord. It also makes sense to go to post shelters as most have them and adopt as well. Most military towns don't blame military for their pet population in the shelters. The civilian side is guilty as well if not more so since BYB's not as cracked down on. In the military you breed you are in serious doo doo, they don't like that stuff in their govt. quarters at all. 

Frogdog --- 15 years ago -

Btw. even for Germans it's sometimes hard to adopt a dog in Germany. There's usually a long request form you have to fill out with all kinds of questions. Those are very carefully reviewed. If everything seems to be ok and it's requirements for the type of dog matches than you will have an inspection of your premises.
A lot of times they also expect you to come to the shelter a few times before you even get the dog so you can spend time with it. If they have the feeling it didn't "click" on the dogs side you are very often denied and they review other possible owners for this dog.
The shelter just wants to make sure that dog doesn't get returned and he found his forever home, cause going through several hands is never good for a dog's soul. 

Kikawow --- 15 years ago -

If it is true then I would totally understand why they don't let us adopt. Look at all the people on grafyardsales (or even just on base) trying to give away their animal (wether they have a good reason for it or not). I mean, they are not a STORE trying to sell products. They don't have to be fake smiling to "customers". They are running shelters, their goal is not to make money but to provide the animals a good human being. And I am happy to hear that the process can be long: you are not the one choosing, you are being chosen or not :} 

Kikawow --- 15 years ago -

Oh, what do you know ... somebody is selling his fishes, his turtle AND his chinchilla because : PCSing.
I'm not judging, it's just another example of how many people don't keep their animals when they PCS.
It may not seem as bad because those are not dogs or cats, but still ... That always worries me when I see those adds, I wonder what kind of person they might end up with. I mean you can see in some adds that they were taking good care of their animals so aren't they afraid to put them in somebody else's hands ? 

Elizabeth --- 15 years ago -

Oh, what do you know ... somebody is selling his fishes, his turtle AND his chinchilla because : PCSing.
I'm not judging, it's just another example of how many people don't keep their animals when they PCS.
It may not seem as bad because those are not dogs or cats, but still ... That always worries me when I see those adds, I wonder what kind of person they might end up with. I mean you can see in some adds that they were taking good care of their animals so aren't they afraid to put them in somebody else's hands ? 


Ok, I think I'm pretty understanding about that guy. Could you imagine traveling with piranhas, turtles, and chinchillas? I don't think many airlines accept those kinds of pet anyways. 

Kikawow --- 15 years ago -

I know it's not really possible to PCS with your fishes, lol ! I just posted this example because I thought it was pretty funny though.
But I am concerned for the chinchilla and the turtle. They are so cute "toys" ... 

pauljw82 --- 15 years ago -

I paid 4300 to PCS my dogs with me.. and another 200 for my cat. Some people arent ready just like some arent ready for kids!! So lets be real here. Its descrimination. You cant generalize Americans because some people neglect their animals. 

Frogdog --- 15 years ago -

Talking about some people aren't ready for it ..
I just have to complain about this, cause it really bugs me:
there's a lady, she looked for a dog a few months ago, got a German Shepherd puppy, sold it recently. Now just a few months later she's selling a Westhighland Terrier puppy, because "jus don't have the tim to dedicate to her" - SERIOUSLY?!? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

graf

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Graf Underground