Graf Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Graf bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

VAT Forms

who's talking here?

Lefteous 2
a3499506uu 1
jmac 1
SnarkySue 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

jmac --- 15 years ago -

Has anyone else used a VAT form only to be surprised when you find out that you don't actually save the 19%? I have used the forms several times over the last year. Used them for various things. And each time the total does not reflect 19%. When ever I ask the merchant about the savings they just snicker and shrug their shoulders and say can't do anything about it. I just wonder if the merchants that accept the VAT form are getting the 19% back fromt he government? Because they are actually only giving about 15-17% off and if they get the full 19% back then they are still making partial tax profit 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Read my "What is an adverb" thread.

Your question reflects a misunderstanding of the math involved.

An item that costs, say 100 Euro, will carry an additional tax of 19 Euro.

100% + 19% = 119%
100 Euro + 19 Euro = 119 Euro

The item will be priced at 119 Euro total.

What you are doing is calculating 19% of the total price, and subtracting that from the total price.

119 Euro x 19% = 22.61 Euro
119 Euro - 22.61 Euro = 96.39 Euro

This is an error. The item costs 100 Euro, remember?

You remember from above that the price on the tag is 119% (1.19 times the real price). Dig back into your algebra and set up a ratio like this:

100% / 119% = X / 119 Euro

The correct calculation, then, is to divide the price on the tag by 1.19.

119 Euro / 1.19 = 100 Euro

I have been out of school for a long time, but I am certain I had this in junior high. Remember being in school and wondering why you were learning things you would never use again? The logic you acquire by doing math is important EVERY DAY. Don't let your kids get snickered at for being undereducated - relearn it yourself, and help them learn it. For every kid out there, learning this stuff is more important than what happened on CSI last night. 

SnarkySue --- 15 years ago -

Lefteous, I think you have too much time on your hands... ;) 

a3499506uu --- 15 years ago -

I wish I was as good at math as he was. I've noticed that I DO save money with the VAT form. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

OK - bottom line cut to the chase:

Divide the price on the item by 1.19 and you get the tax-free price. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls
rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Graf Underground