Graf Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Graf bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com

REALLY ???

who's talking here?

Lefteous 6
a1639983uu 11
earthycrunchy 1
Shubunkin 2
SABRINA 1
melswan 1
memo 1
SnarkySue 2
CrazyMe 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

Did you guys know that retired Army personnel living in Germany have to get a german custom form and pay a fee to be able to shop on-post ? Yet, I see more and more local nationals every day,who are brought on-post by american friends or in-laws doing their shopping at the PX or commisary.Who is checking on that ? What is wrong with that picture huh ? You should be able to keep your benefits no matter where you make your retirement home and not be punished. 

earthycrunchy --- 15 years ago -

Yup I knew this was case........you have to be careful and check where you want to retire now because your benefits just don't seem to go with you. It sucks. My mom is retired military and is coming over to visit for 3 weeks and she is not even allowed to shop in the px/commissary either.
Not quite sure how the healthcare works for retirees over here, that one would scare me and I would maybe have to get German healthcare just to be safe. Things are changing in our country, benefits are going away. 

SnarkySue --- 15 years ago -

I think local nationals that are not married to a military man should have to pay 1,000 Euros for every dollar they spend at our PX/Commissary. That kind of thing REALLY makes me mad. If you think, as a local national, that your family is entitled to shop at our stores, you should be held accountable and pay for it. =\ 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

and what makes me even madder is that they do not try to hide it, they walk through the store and load up the carts in plain sight and then turn them over to the ID card holder at the register.Wonder if both parties know they can get in serious trouble for tax evasion.Why can't we have MP's or security personnel walking the store to keep an eye on that, back in the day they had people checking ID's before entering and you were out of luck if you didn't have one. 

melswan --- 15 years ago -

and what makes me even madder is that they do not try to hide it, they walk through the store and load up the carts in plain sight and then turn them over to the ID card holder at the register


Well , if you haven't noticed most of the cashiers and personnel are GERMANS .. and they KNOW and are AWARE of that but hey they re german too, so well close an eye on that ...damn it i have to show my ID every single time i go there even if they recognize you they still want you to show it ,, sometimes i ll leave mine the car , so i say something like "OH no i forgot to get it from the car, should i go and get it ?" i mean i have my wallet with my usareur licence and other cards and i hope they re nice enough to say it s alright and take in consideration that i have my baby who s acting up with me, but all i get is "YEAH YOU HAVE TO GO GET IT !!!!!!" makes me soooooooo damn upset ! 

SABRINA --- 15 years ago -

They are not supposed to be buying anything!! Family members who do this can get in huge amounts of trouble with customs. Get your local customs office number and make complaints! 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

you know I would call the customs office but guess what, most of them are german...lol.Not hating on the local nationals but they get over big time working for the US government,they get both german and american holidays off, get paid 13th month salary, which is called x-mas pay, drive TMP's around all the time and to top it off get paid more than an american in the same position.Yes I know it's because of the SOFA agreement but I personally think that agreement is outdated and needs to be revised.Oh and did you know that USAG Grafenwoehr offers apprenticeships to young people fresh out of school but this info is withheld from the american community ? I mean come on I would have liked to know about it when my boy graduated. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Everyone in the miltary arena who needs to know this does know it.

The commissary and PX pay the government. The government is happy to have the money the germans bring. They are also happy to have incrased demand mean more minimum wage jobs for dependents and such.

The PX and commissary are in the business of selling, so they are happy to have more customers.

The ones getting hurt by this is the German government. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

increased demands also mean higher prices though and in the end we're all getting hurt. 

SnarkySue --- 15 years ago -

I say screw it, 100% ID check should be in effect, even if they recognize you. They let local nationals buy our stuff without an ID card, but they won't let them into GCSC... something is wrong with this picture. I don't care who you are. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

I totally agree SnarkySue, I think since we've been here I've only them check ID at the entrance twice. 

Shubunkin --- 15 years ago -

Yea, this issue really made me pretty angry today. I wanted to ask how I could complain effectively about it, but all the cashiers were germans. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

we finally made an ICE complaint,still waiting to hear back since we did give our name.I'm sure the people handling those are german also...lol.Now I know in Bamberg they started checking ID's at the entrance finally, if you don't have one you won't enter. 

CrazyMe --- 15 years ago -

I really don't know what yalls problem is, I am german, I even know some of the lady's in the PX and they still check my ID every time no matter who is checking me out. I don't like how they are handling it in Bamberg. I love taking my mom with me so she can help me with my kids, she doesn't want anything from the Px so she is not there to shop but to help me have a good day. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Germans shopping at the Army facilities is good for the Army and soldier families.

What is the objection? Is it just german-hate? 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

it's far from german-hate, I am german myself. All I'm saying is that it is getting out of hand, just this past weekend I ran into a group of about ten people doing their monthly shopping and guess what only one of them was an ID card holder, the one that was his girlfriend apparently brought all her friends with her. Not to even speak of their behaviour which makes me feel embarrassed for my nationality.Now Lefteous, how does it benefit the Army and families ? If they allow them to do it,they also should let the Vets do their shopping but no that's considered tax evasion. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

It is tax evasion either way. What I'm saying is that PX profits go back to the military community. Additional sales means there is need for additional jobs in the PX and Commissary.

What's the problem? Did they run out of milk because the Germans bought it all? What is the complaint?

Everyone in the Army who needs to know this does know it. They aren't doing anything about it because it works for them. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

so why not turn a blind eye to the vets ? They earned their right but it got shoved out of the window. And fyi it does not create more jobs, the commissary is seriously understaffed because they put a freeze on pay-grade jobs. And of course it brings in more money because of supply and demand they can raise the prices. And yes I know we still get stuff cheaper than we would stateside but even so I can still find it cheaper online and the PX won't price match b/c we're overseas.

So how come Bamberg is doing something about it, if as you say it works for the Army ? 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Retirees who are not command supported from another job can shop in the commissary in two ways. One way is just like these Germans; they have a friend with an ID card. The other way is to go through whatever that customs process is; they shop and pay the VAT on their purchases. The Germans do not have that second option.

As to the other stuff, you are too smart for me. Why do you think they do it differently? 

Shubunkin --- 15 years ago -

What makes me angry is when the german non-id card holder has two overfilled carts- who knows if they are really consuming that, or reselling it. It is greedy, and if it is allowed to continue soon we're all gonna be rationed on potato chips and whatever else their cart was heaping full of. This is exactly what happened with the coffee, and now that is why is it rationed (stupidest thing ever!)! 

memo --- 15 years ago -

Sure enough, 100% ID check in effect today. You know, I'm sorry, Lefteous, but it also makes me really mad when this happens. As Big Worm would say, "You see, it's the principal. There's principalities in the whole thing." And to be honest, I really don't give to sh_ts if it's "good for the government" and creating minimum wage jobs. Yeah right. Like I care right now about what is good for the government. As far as I can see (6 months without a job over here), what is good for them is not rolling back down to me, so I'll be dammed if it is going to roll back down to the German citizens/economy. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

@ Lefteous, I would think that Bamberg has a leadership that knows the reg and aren't afraid to implement it unlike at this post. You'd be surprised as to what the LN's get away with, especially working on-post but let's not even go there.
Oh btw, we still haven't gotten a respond back on that ICE complaint, although on the website it states that within 48 hrs of receiving it you will get a respond if you leave your name and email address, well now that didn't work did it ?! Me smells something's rotten in Denmark...lol. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

They were afraid, you think? I think they thought it was good for the community and nobody outside knew or cared.

Everyone in the miltary arena who needs to know this does know it.

...

The ones getting hurt by this is the German government.



This is what I said 25 days ago. The people who care about this are the German Customs Police and the Finanzamt. I imagine the ID card check now is to protect the Army from them, since it is becoming an issue. After all, we are guests in their country.

I still wonder why the jealousy is there. I am a retiree who does not have logistical support, one of the ones who is effected as in the OP. I understand what the rule is and why. It isn't a question of the Army not allowing retirees to shop at the commissary. The issue is that retirees are not covered under SOFA and therefor have no tax-free privileges. If a German spouse brings her family in to shop, I'm not screaming, I would love to go shopping once in a while too (if I had any friends - hehe).

@Shubunkin Coffee Tea and Soluables (sugar) have been rationed items since I got here in 1990, and were also rationed when I was here in the 70s. There must be some kind of agreement covering that, not shortages. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

hmmm, I don't remember coffee being rationed back in the 80's but hey my memory could be failing me since I am getting old...lol. I understand that a german spouse will bring his/her family but it doesn't stop there, they bring friends which in turn bring their friends and so on, you get the pic. As for you being a retiree without support I'm sorry, I know plenty of retirees who stick to the rules and get their customs form instead of using friends with IDs and I respect them for that. 

Lefteous --- 15 years ago -

Sure, I'm one of them. I'm not resentful that Germans are in the store though.

What I hope is that the ID checking will not expand to keeping me out of the place unless I have the forms - this could get bigger than you wanted it to be. 

a1639983uu --- 15 years ago -

I'm not resentful, just voicing my opinion which is that it is getting out of hand, where does it stop ? Well, and I seriously doubt that one voice will change common practice. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Graf Underground